After Belavezha Accord was signed, Yeltsin and the crew had to placate Kazakhstan that everything will be alright, and they were the last to agree to dissolution. Kazakhstan was one country that mourn it actually. More than Russia itself.
Tuesday, December 26, 2023
Why Kazakhstan Was Most Supportive of Continuation of USSR
Sunday, December 24, 2023
Russian Stereotypes about Different Countries - Slavic Trio
Language Issue
Outcomes
How Propaganda prevails over the reality
Ukraine
Belarus
Russian Stereotypes about Different Countries - Introduction
Stereotypes often shape the way; people see other people and countries. Other people are complicated, and it is expediate to simplify them into some easy to digest and understand stereotype. Sometimes these stereotypes are very far from reality, but they often hold powerful sway over people, nonetheless. Like Myth of Liberator Gorbachev continues to re-appear even in more informed videos.
Thus, I decided to write a comprehensive article about myth that persist in Russia about various countries in the world. I do know that many of it is vastly inaccurate and does not reflect reality of people in question. However, these are the thing Russian media, education and even entertainment perpetrate. Thing average guy on the streets of Moscow or Ekaterinburg likely to believe.
It is important to understand these stereotypes, as some of Russian geo-political actions, such as war in Ukraine as well as people's reaction to it, are direct consequence of these myth.
Former USSR
I will begin with former USSR. 15 Soviet Republics, united in an "unbreakable brotherly union" were a common theme of various "educational" propaganda. United, but with their own unique colorful characteristics, similar to four countries of the UK. They are often grouped together in geographically related groups: Baltic trio, Slavic trio, Caucasian trio, Central Asia, Moldova on its own.
Slavic and Baltic trios represented the "us vs them" dichotomy: Slav trio is Russia's extended family; Baltics, and especially Latvia, is an example the collective West as it is understood by people in Russia.
Saturday, December 23, 2023
Russian Stereotypes about Different Countries - Baltic States
Baltic States
Latvia
Estonia
Lithuania
Final words
Thursday, December 21, 2023
How Medieval Society Worked
Only every nobleman: baron and above (viscount, count (Earl), Marquess, Duke, Prince, King, Emperor) had a Coat of Arms
How Quartered Designs on Various Coat of Arms Came to Be
Quartered designs, that people imitate so often, come not from single time intentional design, but from mergers and such.
Wednesday, December 20, 2023
LNP Party Room Problem
When Liberal and National parties of Queensland merged into one party, it created a peculiar problem for The Coalition. That is a party room distribution.
Liberal and National MPs each have their own separate party rooms, they do not have joint Coalition Party Room. Thus, only MPs of their respective parties participate in all important internal governance of their parties: National MPs do not vote on leader of Liberal Party and Liberal MPs do not vote on leader of the National Party.
That used to limit radical far right MPs influence on politics. Sure, Nationals do get some portfolios, but they have no say over who gets any portfolios on Liberal side of Coalition, or who will be new Liberal leader.
However, when LNP was created, instead of getting their own party room, they made a peculiar arrangement with the Federal parties: 2 out of 3 LNP MPs will be in Liberal Party room and the remaining one out of 3 in National Party room instead.
That shifted the power balance in Liberal Part room far to the right. A lot of rural MP, who would have been in National Party room under old arrangement, were now in the Liberal Party room instead. That affected preselection of leaders in the Liberals. Suddenly radicals such as Tony Abbot or Peter Dutton could become leaders of this otherwise moderate party.
Because of that, the Australian politics overall shifted far to the right. What used to be fringe rural sentiments now suddenly seeped through to the mainstream. In fact, the whole mess of the 2010s should be blamed on this subtle party room arrangement.
The solution to this problem will be to replace this arrangement with something that reflects reality better. One solution is all rural LNP MPs sit with the Nationals and only urban with the Liberals. The other one is LNP is getting its own party room, elects its own leader who becomes second deputy PM if coalition wins, and they get some agreed on portfolios, just like Nationals currently do.
I do hope this will be solved, the sooner the better.
Wednesday, December 13, 2023
How Losers become Winners
I once wrote a large article about how once huge and powerful empires eventually crumbled and turned into dust. However, this process has its own opposite, how once outcasts and losers turned tables around and became great. In fact, some of these great empires clearly had a miserable beginning, with some others there is not enough information to be clear. However, there was no any cohesive evidence of any great power, that was destined for greatness from the start.
The US
We can begin with the United States itself. Give or take the only current superpower.US had near humblest beginnings out there. Some of it even preserved in stories about pilgrims of the Plymouth Bay colony, that is in modern Massachusetts, where Boston and MIT are.
What is now the US, began as leftover colonies of the Spanish. By the time French and British found out about the new world, Spanish and Portuguese pretty much colonized all valuable land there. So, these two and the Dutch hat to make do with what Spanish could not be bothered with. Modern US and Canada mostly.
The people who settled it were also somewhat of an outcast of the original societies from which they relocated to the Americas.
For example, Pilgrims were followers of the Puritan Religion, one of the strands of the Protestant Reformation. However, their extreme version of the Christianity eventually provoked ire of British government, who ordered them all to either convent to Anglicanism or leave the UK. Those who left founded Plymouth Bay colony that eventually evolved into Massachusetts Bay Colony and then the US State of Massachusetts as well as other states in the New England Region.
Southern colonists came from more upper class, but no less unfortunate background. Planters of the South were second and third children of nobility. Nobles first born would be groomed to eventually succeed their father as next Lord (peer). However, there was only one title to inherit, so if any given baron had two sons, only one could become Lord after their father's death and enjoy the powers and privilege that brings. The second will do without, so they had no choice but finding their own place in the world and building their wealth from ground up. Some of such gentlemen found their opportunity in American south and set up cotton plantations there. Being sons of Manorial Lords, they organized these plantations in a similar way, substituting peasants for slaves from Africa.
Middle states, such as New York and Delaware were once Dutch and Swedish colonies respectively. However, these countries could not profit from them, so they abandoned them. the British and the US picked them up. Dutch literary traded whole modern state of New York for what is now Suriname, back in the days Suriname was more profitable and prosperous, so Dutch ditched the big apple for some sugar plantations.
The trend continued and even intensified when the US became independent. It became an immigration magnet for impoverished and discontent from Europe and eventually the rest of the world.
On the dais Statue of Liberty, that welcomes new arrivals by see there is even an inscription: "Give me your tired, your poor/Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free."
These outcasts not needed elsewhere became Americans and eventually took this country into greatness.
Russia
The US rival from Cold War times, where people sometimes like to pride themselves on not being a bunch of mixed origins immigrants from all over the world, is actually no less mixed than the US.
Back in Peter I times, there was even the special foreign districts where various immigrants from Europe will live. Eventually this practice was abolished, but the people from there simply intermixed with the rest of the population.
Both Peter I and Catherine II as well as all the monarchs between them employed Europeans on many important governmental positions. Scotsman Gordon build Peter I navy and Genevan Frenchman Le Fort built fortifications and artillery; the infamous Lefortovo neighborhood is named after him. Main street of Odessa, Deribasovskaya, is actually named after Jose de Ribas, a Spainard who participated in building this city.
Peter I was not the first who employed foreigners in Russia.
Kievan Rus was founded by the adventurer Rurik from what is now modern Scandinavia. Rurik too thought to improve his lot by going Viking, because back in the days Sweden was not as prosperous as it is now. Rurik and his Scandianvians intermixed with local Slavs and Finno-Ugric people. They relationships with Byzantine Empire brought some Greeks in as well.
Moscow and its state were founded by yet another second son of one Rurikid Prince. Once again older brother could inherit Kyiv or other established city and a younger one had to go to uncharted land and found his own city to rule over.
Moscowy founders were especially unlucky, because unlike other Rurikids, their first 2 attempts at founding a viable city failed. Rostov and Suzdal has enough fancy buildings for a princely capital, but poor location eventually forced princes to re-found their capital elsewhere. Back in the days, trade and shipping went over the rivers. Unless a city is founded on a river, trade and logistics becomes near impossible. However, founders of Rostov and Suzdal had to learn it from their own mistakes.
Australia
UK and Europe
Some people like to see the UK as an example of fanciness and high culture. However, that was not always the case. For a long time, England was a periphery state of little importance. Only after the 7 Years War, the UK got in the spotlight.
Austria allied England to counterbalance French alliance with Brandenburg-Prussia. England was considered as important as one single prince elector in the Holy Roman Empire, even if double titled Margrave and Duke. Just like England, Brandenburg too eventually became important and unified Germany around itself.
Before that high politics, technology and social advancement were done by Dutch France, Austria and Ottomans. Before even that by Spanish and Portuguese and Italians, everyone else was lagging behind. Before even that Byzantine Empire was an heir to Rome and everyone else was considered a barbarian.
Conclusion
Saturday, December 9, 2023
Politicians of Different Generations
Sometimes it is hard to get a clear picture of how each generation is different from each other in politics. However, there is one country where, there is a politician for pretty much every generation imaginable. The country's name is Czech Republic
Andrej Babish of the Boomers
Petr Fiala of the Generation W
Vit Rakushan of Xennials
Ivan Bartosh of Millennials
How Different Eras Were Dominated by One or Another Generation
Different generations have different characteristics as well as different understanding of what is important and what is not. However there happen periods in history, where concerns of one or the other generation become dominant and shape the life of everyone around them for decades or even longer.
Each generation
Greatest Generation and Cold War
We will begin with Greatest/Veteran Generation (born before 1926). In their youth these guys saw how war destroyed their cities and lives into rubble. Many lost their friends in fighting. Many fought and killed on the battlefield. All these experiences made them hate and fear war. Trust their comrades and allies, rally around their flag. Hate their enemies and be ready to fight against them.
Because of that patriotism, security and material needs became dominant themes during the Cold War era. All the things they missed so dearly during the WWII times.
By 1953, after Stalin died and Eisenhower replaced Truman as President of the US, these guys were firmly in control in both USA and USSR. They were more or less in control until the Eastern Bloc and USSR collapse in 1991. A period, known as Cold War: almost 4 decades of Greatest Generation rule.
Their fear of war, together with destruction and privation it brings, shaped this era. Both wanted to avoid the new war, but neither was willing or able to trust the other one. They both remembered Nazi atrocities and privations of war. They grew to blame Nazi for starting the war and therefore demonized Nazis as well as each other.
Going without during war, made them value basic material good highly. Things such as food clothes and housing became priorities of each government during Cold War. Lyndon B. Johnson's Great Society was one of the ways to address these material concerns of this generations.
Housing was a particular concern for both. The US had Fannie May and Freddie Mac to provide housing to its people. They keep giving out subsidized home loans all the way to 2008 to make sure no one goes without roof over their head. Both Khruschev and Brezhnev paid great attention to housing, possibly issues with Khruschev times homes, called Khruschevka, even led to Khruschev own downfall. Brezhnev first thing in his reign, did addressed all the design issues, Kruschevkas had in his later designs.
Raw memories of war atrocities made them un-willing to even consider that enemy on the other side of Berlin wall anything less that devil incarnate. Thus, propaganda was widespread and omnipresent. Of course, they eventually went overboard with that. What first begun as natural cautiousness against horrors of war, overtime became stubborn ignorant inflexibility.
Thus, all sort of security measures against traitors, who conspire with the enemy or even question the current system often were common. Loyalty to one's side was considered paramount to preventing enemy from attacking. So is high military and technological spending. These sectors saw huge progress during the Cold War Era. Computers became a thing, so is smart weapons that can fight on their own.
Boomers during Cold War Era
Boomers after Cold War
World, Millennials Grew Up In
Other Generations
Millennial Era
More on The US Democratic Party
I thought about it more and reached a rather unorthodox conclusion on the US Democratic Party. The party was taken over by some radical insa...
-
A while ago I wrote that political compass fails to represent political opinions clearly enough. By now four squares political compass bec...
-
I recently got this interesting idea on how to improve European Union. They should split bigger countries into several smaller ones. Or at t...
-
I recently got good idea on how to solve Ukraine war situation. They should do massive land swap. Ukraine should give Russia Crimea, Sevas...